In a world overflowing with entertainment options, it’s easy to miss out on some of the best TV shows that are quietly gaining critical acclaim but haven’t quite hit the mainstream. While the most talked-about shows like Game of Thrones or Stranger Things dominate the headlines, there are countless hidden gems that deserve more attention. These shows may not have the same massive fanbase, but their storytelling, acting, and innovation make them stand out in a crowded TV landscape. Here are some of the best TV shows you’re not watching, but absolutely should be.
1. The Leftovers (HBO)
In a world where post-apocalyptic narratives are a dime a dozen, The Leftovers stands out by tackling existential questions in a profoundly emotional and thought-provoking way. The show, created by Damon Lindelof and Tom Perrotta, centers on the aftermath of a mysterious event in which 2% of the world’s population inexplicably vanishes. While the premise is intriguing, the heart of The Leftovers lies in its exploration of grief, faith, and the search for meaning in an increasingly chaotic world.
Set in a small town in New York, the series focuses on the lives of the people left behind, including a police chief (Justin Theroux) and a mother (Carrie Coon) who is struggling with the loss of her family. As the show progresses, it delves deeper into the psychological and philosophical impacts of this unexplained event, while balancing human emotions with surreal moments. The Leftovers challenges viewers to confront questions about life, loss, and the human need for connection.
Although it never reached the level of mainstream fame enjoyed by other HBO hits, The Leftovers is widely considered a modern TV masterpiece. Its thoughtful narrative, exceptional performances, and stunning cinematography make it a must-watch for anyone seeking a show that’s as intellectually stimulating as it is emotionally devastating.
2. Halt and Catch Fire (AMC)
Halt and Catch Fire might not have attracted the massive following it deserved, but it’s an unsung gem of television that tells the fascinating story of the early days of personal computing and the rise of the internet. Set in the 1980s and early 1990s, the show chronicles a group of visionary engineers and entrepreneurs in Silicon Prairie, Texas, as they navigate the competitive world of tech innovation.
The heart of Halt and Catch Fire lies in its complex characters and their personal struggles. Lee Pace plays Joe MacMillan, a charming but troubled salesman with a vision of revolutionizing the tech industry, while Mackenzie Davis portrays Cameron Howe, a talented but rebellious computer programmer. The show explores their ambitions, friendships, and romantic entanglements while delving into the ethical dilemmas and interpersonal conflicts that arise in the cutthroat tech world.
Unlike many shows that focus purely on business and technology, Halt and Catch Fire makes room for character-driven storytelling, delving into how technology changes human relationships and the dynamics of the workplace. It’s a show about innovation, ambition, and the pursuit of dreams, but it’s also about personal growth, vulnerability, and the human cost of success.
Despite its lack of mainstream popularity, Halt and Catch Fire has a dedicated following and is considered one of the best examples of how TV can capture both the spirit of innovation and the emotional journey of its characters. If you’re interested in a show that mixes tech history with personal drama, Halt and Catch Fire is a must-watch.
3. Counterpart (Starz)
Counterpart is a mind-bending sci-fi thriller that has gone under the radar despite its incredibly unique premise and sharp execution. Starring J.K. Simmons in a dual role, the show revolves around Howard Silk, a mild-mannered bureaucrat who discovers that his company, a seemingly mundane espionage organization, is involved in interdimensional espionage. The show’s plot revolves around the existence of parallel worlds, where each person has a counterpart on the other side.
At its core, Counterpart is a deep exploration of identity, morality, and the choices that define who we are. Simmons’s brilliant performance, where he plays both a timid, ordinary man and his much more confident and ruthless counterpart, adds incredible depth to the show. His character’s evolution, along with the intricate, tension-filled narrative, keeps viewers on the edge of their seats.
The show blends elements of espionage, science fiction, and psychological thriller, creating a tense atmosphere that explores the philosophical implications of living in a world with alternate versions of ourselves. As the stakes rise and the plot delves into themes of trust, betrayal, and self-discovery, Counterpart becomes a riveting experience.
Despite critical acclaim, Counterpart never gained a large following, which is a shame given its clever premise and strong performances. It’s a show that’s perfect for fans of cerebral sci-fi, character-driven narratives, and intricate plots.
4. Brockmire (IFC)
If you’re looking for a dark comedy with a unique premise, Brockmire is a hidden gem that blends humor with a sharp, satirical commentary on the world of sports broadcasting. The show stars Hank Azaria as Jim Brockmire, a disgraced baseball announcer who returns to the industry after a public meltdown. Set in the world of minor league baseball, Brockmire follows Jim’s attempts to rebuild his career while navigating a series of eccentric characters and outrageous situations.
What sets Brockmire apart from other comedies is its mix of absurd humor with moments of surprising emotional depth. It’s a show that isn’t afraid to tackle serious issues like addiction, depression, and personal redemption, all while maintaining a sharp, irreverent sense of humor. Azaria delivers a stellar performance, balancing the character’s absurdities with a sense of vulnerability and pathos.
Although Brockmire may not be on many people’s radar, it has earned a loyal fanbase thanks to its smart writing, witty dialogue, and Azaria’s unforgettable performance. If you enjoy dark comedies with a blend of humor and heart, Brockmire should be at the top of your list.
5. The Terror (AMC)
For fans of historical fiction with a chilling twist, The Terror is an underrated series that blends horror with real-life events. Based on Dan Simmons’s novel, the show tells the story of a British expedition in the 19th century that becomes trapped in the Arctic after their ships become icebound. As the crew struggles to survive in the freezing, desolate environment, they must also face a mysterious and deadly force lurking in the ice.
What makes The Terror so captivating is its combination of historical accuracy and supernatural horror. The show expertly captures the brutal conditions of the Arctic while weaving a suspenseful and terrifying narrative. As tensions rise and the crew begins to unravel, The Terror becomes an exploration of human endurance, fear, and survival.
Though The Terror is sometimes overshadowed by more popular horror shows, it has garnered praise for its atmosphere, compelling performances, and ability to mix historical fiction with supernatural horror. With its moody, slow-burning tension and expertly crafted storyline, The Terror is a must-watch for fans of historical thrillers and horror alike.
6. The Expanse (Amazon Prime Video)
The Expanse is one of the best sci-fi shows of the decade, but it’s still flying under the radar for many viewers. Set in a future where humanity has colonized the solar system, the show explores the political, social, and economic conflicts between Earth, Mars, and the Belt. When a missing person case leads to the discovery of a dangerous alien substance, a conspiracy unfolds that threatens to unravel the fragile balance of power in the solar system.
The show is lauded for its complex world-building, rich character development, and thought-provoking exploration of power, inequality, and the human condition. The ensemble cast, which includes Steven Strait, Thomas Jane, and Shohreh Aghdashloo, brings the world of The Expanse to life, creating a tense, immersive atmosphere. The show tackles issues such as class struggle, resource scarcity, and the ethical dilemmas of space exploration, making it a standout in the sci-fi genre.
While The Expanse has earned critical acclaim, it hasn’t gained the mass following of other popular sci-fi franchises. However, those who have discovered the show are ardent fans, and for good reason. If you enjoy thought-provoking sci-fi with deep political intrigue and moral complexity, The Expanse is an absolute must-watch.
Conclusion: Why You Should Watch These Shows
In a world where it’s easy to get lost in the endless sea of content, these underrated TV shows stand out for their incredible writing, innovative storytelling, and unforgettable performances. Whether you’re into deep philosophical questions, intense drama, or thrilling sci-fi, these shows have something for everyone. So, if you’re tired of the same old mainstream hits, give these hidden gems a shot. You might just find your next favorite show.